top of page

Practical tips and insights for higher ed leaders. Straight to your inbox.

Share this Article on:

Why Smart Leaders Fill Up on Breadsticks

8 hours ago
6 min read
Why Smart Leaders Fill Up on Breadsticks

NOVEMBER 21, 2026 · 7 MINUTE READ

👉 Before we dive in: a favor

Almost every campus I work with has a strategic plan. Far fewer can tell you whether it’s working, or why.

Nicki Nabasny and I want to change that. Our national study asks how strategic plans are developed, communicated, and carried out, and what actually helps them succeed. There’s plenty of planning on campuses and very little data on what makes plans effective.

If you work at a U.S. college or university and have helped build or carry out a plan, as a chair, dean, provost, president, faculty member, or staff member, we’d value your perspective. It’s anonymous, takes 15-18 minutes, and closes December 14.

And if you know a colleague who has lived through a plan, please forward this to them. People in different roles see the same plan differently, and we need all of those views. We’ll share the findings in a free webinar on January 28.


“It is not enough to be industrious; so are the ants. What are you industrious about?” Henry David Thoreau

One of the perils of dining out is the light appetizer they set on the table while you wait for your main course to arrive.

It might be breadsticks, a bucket of peanuts, or chips and salsa. Nobody orders them, but there they are, and somehow my hand finds the basket before my brain weighs in (…or maybe that's just me). More than once, I've been hungry and enjoying the conversation so much that I kept snacking without thinking about it. By the time the entrée arrived, I barely had room for the meal I came for.

Many leaders I speak to and coach struggle with the same thing. At work, the appetizers are small requests: a document to review, a form to fill out, a question over email we could answer in our sleep. They're hard to turn down, because they're easy, they won't take that long, and saying yes even feels like helping. So we keep saying yes until, by the end of the week, we're full, and there's no room left for the main course. The work only we can do is the meal we came for, and we've crowded it out with appetizers.

The Leadership Takeaway

Our capacity becomes our trap. Those of us who can say yes and still deliver are often the first to be asked, and every yes invites the next request. And because we can absorb the extra work, nobody stops us, including ourselves. Beyond the usual advice about boundaries and time management, the more useful question is why we keep saying yes.

Most of us were offered leadership roles for being that person. We taught the extra section, wrote the report, and served on every committee. Once we lead, our job changes from doing one piece of the work to looking after the whole. We set the direction, see how the pieces fit together, shape the culture, develop the people around us, and advocate for our unit to those above us. That's the main course. Our perspective on the whole unit becomes a large part of how we contribute.

I find many new leaders play down their own perspective. They hold back their leadership viewpoint, as if it counted for less than everyone else's. Most of us don't want to seem self-important, step on toes, or put distance between ourselves and our colleagues. Speaking up gets harder because the people now doing the work we used to do don't always see what leadership involves. Setting direction and weighing tradeoffs happen mostly out of view. So our value, and the particular way we contribute, can stay hidden. If you've held back your viewpoint for these reasons, your heart is in the right place, and it's a generous instinct.

But when we aren't clear about how we contribute as leaders, the old work encroaches on the new job. We drift back to the work that's known and comfortable, that we're good at, and that makes us feel like one of the group. Those are the appetizers. And while we're filling up on them, the conversations that shape our unit's future can miss a view of how all the pieces fit together. If we don't understand what that view adds, chances are nobody else will either.

What the Appetizers Are Feeding

Getting clear about how we contribute starts with knowing what those appetizers give us. Each one feeds a real need we crave, and once we name it, we can meet it through the work only we can and should do. The needs vary from person to person, but here are three that show up often in leaders:

1. Relevance Relevance is the need to feel needed. Appetizers make us useful right now, and they give us something concrete to point to at the end of the day. We attended the meeting, drafted the document, or fixed the problem. Very little else in a leader's week offers such quick proof that we matter.

The work of the main course feeds relevance too, though in less visible ways. We're needed for the decisions nobody else can make. We're needed to connect the pieces, so problems get spotted before they become a crisis. And we're needed to grow the people around us, building their capacity and their leadership skills. Peers can't easily do that for one another, and it's what effective leaders do.

2. Worth Worth is the need to feel capable. Appetizers are work we know we're good at, and doing them well (let's be honest) feels good! Psychologists Richard Ryan and Edward Deci identified competence as a basic psychological need, and leadership work doesn't always make us feel competent. Many of us are learning on the job, in front of an audience of faculty, staff, and students. So the appetizer becomes a place to feel capable. It's the same pull I wrote about in The VP Who Vacuumed His Own Office.

In leadership, capability looks different. The main course feeds worth through how we use our position and influence. We can open a door, find the funding, or make the call that helps someone accomplish what they couldn't have done alone. Our worth shows up in what other people are able to do because we were in the role.

3. Belonging Belonging is the need to feel part of the group. Appetizers keep us close to the work our people do and give us a way to say, "I'm still one of you." Roy Baumeister and Mark Leary called the need to belong a fundamental human motivation.

In my opinion, belonging is the hardest of these three needs. Even a colleague we worked beside for decades will see us as their boss. Will it feel the same as it did before we led? It won't, and it helps to name the difference, at least to ourselves. The main course still feeds belonging, though. We belong by having a part to play and a way to add value to the group, without trying to be like everyone else or giving in to groupthink. Teams trust leaders who are clear about their role, and they relax when they know what we're there to do.


Try This Before Friday

Think of the last appetizer you said yes to: a meeting you didn't need to attend, a task someone else owns, a problem you fixed yourself. Ask yourself what need it fed. It might be relevance, worth, or belonging, or it might be one that's yours alone. Then pick the main-course work that would give you that same feeling, and make time for it by the end of the day Friday.

You may decide that appetizer was worth it, and sometimes it is. The aha is that passing on the appetizer doesn't leave the need unfed. The main course can meet it too.

Bottom Line

The hunger behind the appetizers is legitimate. We want to matter, we want to be good at something, and we want to belong. None of that goes away when we take the job, and it shouldn't. Those instincts are a big part of why people trusted us with the role in the first place.

So every so often, we push the breadsticks to the other side of the table and make room for the meal we came for. The direction we set, the culture we shape, and the people we develop will outlast anything we could have checked off this week. Most of that work happens out of sight, and the people it helps may never see it. They'll feel it, though, and that's the kind of mattering worth saving room for.

Thanks for reading today. Here's to the work only you can do.



Put this to work on your campus.

Group coaching opens this spring

If you'd like to work on this with a small group of peers, I'll be running a group coaching cohort this spring. If you're interested in hearing more, join the waitlist.

🏛️ FOR INSTITUTIONS

Strategic Planning and Leadership Development

I work with campuses in three ways: partnering with leadership teams on alignment and decision-making, facilitating strategic planning from mission through execution, and running cohort programs that develop leaders at every level, from chairs and directors to deans.

💡 FOR INDIVIDUAL LEADERS

Executive Coaching

Few campus leaders get the development the role requires, so most learn it in real time, in front of the people they lead. I work 1:1 with academic leaders, from department chairs to provosts and vice presidents, who are getting ready for the next role or want one person outside the institution to work through complex issues with. A few spots open each quarter.


© 2026 Kevin Sanders | Cornerstone Leadership Group LLC  |  FAQs  |  Privacy

  • KS (180 x 180 px)-2
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page